If quality shut-eye is eluding you and you’ve done just about everything to improve your sleep, it might be time to point the finger at your mattress.
An old, lumpy mattress with limited support can mess with your sleep and potentially leave you with aches and pains.
By replacing your mattress with a brand-new model that provides plenty of support and comfortable cushioning for your body, you can rest easier.
Though comfort varies by person, we’ve rounded up mattresses with great reviews to help you in your search for a better night’s sleep.
Here’s what we kept in mind when making our picks for the most comfortable mattresses:
- Brand reputation: This is important to us. We only include mattresses from brands with solid track records and a decent Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating.
- Safety: Mattresses all meet federal flammability requirements.
- Certifications: We look at things like third-party certifications (e.g., CertiPUR-US) and whether a company has transparent business practices.
- Trial period: Picking a mattress is pretty personal. What someone else finds soft and luxurious might not feel the same to you, so being able to try it at home is key.
- Warranty: We only considered models that come with a warranty of at least 10 years.
- Reviews: In addition to looking at models with rave reviews, we also looked at models that reviewers frequently described as comfortable.
- Healthline scores: In addition to our vetting process, we went a step further and created our own scores for these mattresses based on our criteria on what makes a mattress more valuable to you.
Mattresses can feel incredibly different from one another. And your preferences play a huge role in determining whether a mattress feels comfortable or not.
While your personal comfort parameters may vary, here’s what you might want to consider when shopping for a mattress.
Trial period
In the process of trying to find the most comfortable mattress, being able to try it before you buy is crucial. Look for brands that offer a generous trial period and an uncomplicated return process.
Motion isolation
Motion isolation might be something to keep in mind if you sleep with a partner or pet. Memory foam is better at dampening movement than an innerspring mattress.
Still, not everyone loves the feel of an all-foam mattress. Hybrids provide a decent middle ground.
Firmness
This is relatively subjective, so it might be helpful to know what you like before you shop.
How’s your current mattress? Does it feel too soft? Too hard? Evaluating your existing sleep surface might help point you in the right direction.
According to one 2015 review of studies, many people find a medium-firm mattress to be the most comfortable and conducive to a good night’s sleep.
Temperature control
Temperature also plays a crucial role in keeping you comfortable. If you sleep hot, look for a mattress with breathable materials.
You might also want to consider hybrid instead of foam since foam tends to sleep hot, though that’s not true of all models.
Still counting sheep to fall asleep?
Check out our article on sleep trends and see if they can help you get some rest. Also, check out our natural sleep aid recommendations if you need a little extra help falling asleep.
A hybrid mattress contains both innerspring and foam. It tends to be more responsive than foam, but that also means you’ll feel more movement from a bed partner.
Flipping your mattress might extend its life span, but not all mattresses are flippable. If you cannot flip your mattress, try rotating it to prevent uneven wear and tear.
Expect to replace your mattress every 7 to 10 years, on average. You’ll know it’s time when you start to notice reduced sleep quality on a regular basis.
Having a quality mattress is a great way to promote sound sleep, but comfort is subjective.
Don’t be afraid to try different mattress models and take advantage of free trial periods to find the mattress of your dreams.